Most leaders have faced this moment. A role opens up, or the business grows into needing one, and there’s a manager everyone points to. Great results. Dependable. Knows the business inside and out.
And yet there’s a flicker of hesitation. You don’t doubt them. You just realize you’re not sure.
That hesitation is worth paying attention to. I believe it’s usually pointing at something real.
Results Measure the Job They Have
Results tell you how well someone handles the role they’re in today. They don’t tell you how that person will handle a bigger scope, more people, and decisions with higher stakes. Those are different tests, and strong performance in one doesn’t guarantee a pass in the other.
So when I think about readiness, I look past the numbers to how someone leads the people around them. Do they address problems early, or do they wait until they’ve grown? Do you hear about trouble from them first, or from someone else? Are the people on their team growing because of how they lead? Does the team keep moving when they’re out for a week?
I don’t treat any of these as a scorecard. But the patterns tell me more than a strong quarter does.
Stretch Before You Promote
I’m a big believer in letting a promising manager stretch before the decision is on the table. Give them a cross-functional project, a temporary expansion of scope, or something outside their usual territory.
It gives you real evidence instead of a hunch. It also gives them a chance to find out whether they actually want the bigger role, which isn’t always the case. Some of the best conversations I’ve seen about careers started with someone saying, “I tried it, and I’m not sure it’s for me.”
The Fair Pushback
Some leaders will tell me you never really know until someone is in the seat. There’s truth in that. Every promotion carries some risk.
There’s a difference between a leap and a well-informed step. You can’t remove the uncertainty, but you can shrink it.
So I’m curious. Think about the best promotions you’ve made. What did you see in those people beforehand? And for the ones that didn’t work out, what do you wish you had noticed?
I’d love to hear what you’ve learned.
11710 Plaza America Drive, Suite 2000 Reston, VA 20190
703.278.CORE (2673)
Leave a Reply