We have spent several weeks talking about how to develop your mid-managers. Invest in them. Build them into the leaders your organization needs. But this week I want to pause and ask a harder question.
Are the right people in those seats in the first place?
This is not comfortable territory. Because leaving someone in a role they are fundamentally misaligned with feels easier: less conflict, less disruption, less of the hard conversation nobody wants to initiate.
But that comfort has a cost. And it is one of the most expensive silences in a growing organization.
What Misalignment Actually Looks Like
A misaligned manager rarely causes a dramatic crisis. What they create is quieter and more damaging, accumulating below the surface, attributed to other causes, invisible on any report.
It shows up as slightly higher turnover than expected. Capable direct reports who are somehow not thriving. An atmosphere that is hard to name but unmistakably off.
And the people closest to the problem almost never tell you what is really happening. They cite compensation on the way out. A better opportunity. The real answer is simpler: they did not feel led well, and they did not believe that was going to change.
I worked with a leadership team that discovered this the hard way. One manager’s direct reports had been leaving at an unusual rate for nearly a year before anyone connected it to leadership.
When they dug deeper, it was not a skills problem. It was a fundamental mismatch of values, style, and approach. A capable person in the wrong seat. Every month without that conversation cost them talent and culture that took years to rebuild.
Development First. But Do Not Confuse the Two.
Most struggling managers are not misaligned (in the wrong seat). They are underdeveloped, capable people, promoted without the tools to succeed. That is solvable.
But some managers are genuinely in the wrong seat. Not because they lack skills, but because of who they are and how they fundamentally operate. No development changes that.
The danger is confusing one for the other. Investing in development when the real issue is alignment prolongs damage. Writing someone off too quickly when they needed real support discards a potential leader. Both errors are expensive.
The Responsibility You Cannot Delegate
When a misaligned manager stays too long and is making life genuinely difficult for the people beneath them, that accountability does not rest only with the manager. It rests with the senior leader who saw the signals and chose not to act.
Your best people will eventually stop waiting and make a move you cannot reverse.
The courageous call is not always development. Sometimes it is clarity. Be honest with yourself about what you are seeing and direct with the individual about what the role requires.
Think about the manager you have been uncertain about. Ask honestly: have they received real, structured development or have you been hoping the situation resolves itself?
If development has been thin, start there. Every time.
But if the investment has been genuine and the misalignment persists, if this is a values gap and not a skills gap then one question becomes urgent.
How much longer will the people below them pay that price?
11710 Plaza America Drive, Suite 2000 Reston, VA 20190
703.278.CORE (2673)
Leave a Reply